£15 Amazon Gift Voucher when you buy any iPod Nano!

Sunday, 7 November, 2010

Treyc Cohen leaves the X Factor

Katie and Treyc polled the lowest number of votes and were in the bottom two this week – both of them having previously been in the bottom two.

Katie struggled through her performance of Please Don’t Give Up On Me, at one point saying “You know what, sod it!” and sitting down.

As a result it was a huge surprise when Treyc was voted off the show by the judges.

Treyc sang Un-Break My Heart, but was inexplicably voted out by Simon and Louis. Louis said that his head was telling him to keep Treyc in the competition, but he went with his heart.

Treyc said that she thought she failed to connect with the viewing public. Even Katie seemed shocked to still be in the competition.


  1. Utterly wrong decision!!!!! Won’t be watching any more.

    Comment by jeanh — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:01

  2. i think cheryl cole should have taken it to dead lock everyone knew that thats what she meant

    Comment by toni rayner — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:03

  3. Compleatly wrong!!! Katie’s been in the bottom two three times now!! DOn’t the judges get the public don’t like her!!!

    Comment by ILuvMatt!!! — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:04

  4. This is all wrong,Cheryl said she would take it to deadlock,not forfit her vote rewind your Sky+ that is what she said.She said she would vote last not give up her vote.To eliminate Trajce was wrong go it should have gone to deadlock.

    Comment by Liamjb — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:05

  5. what a joke cheryl cole has made a complete mockery of the whole thing.
    would be gutted if i was treyc got no support from her mentor

    Comment by kay — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:05

  6. The xfactor has always been my fav show and to be honest i don’t think I will be watching it anymore… whats the point its an absolute joke… firstly its cheryl’s job to vote, you can’t just decide not to vote, secondly it is obvious the public do not like Katie, yet the Judges keep saving her?? Why when its meant to the publics choice?? Love the way she forgot the wrods AGAIN by the way. Extremely frustrating to watch, not entertaining anymore

    Comment by Linda — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:06

  7. Why wasn’t Mary wearing a poppy tonight it’s very dis-respectful.

    Comment by Holly — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:07

  8. totally disagreed with that, TreyC is far better … they want the contraversy – its not on my sky plus anymore

    Comment by Carol S — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:08

  9. wat is x factor all about!!!!! singers i thought, simon was wrong he don’t know wat the viewers think it should of gone deadlock.cheryl should of voted she is a judge after all, x factor is getting a joke i’m so angry katie is still in she sat down & gave up she knew she was going thats y she is crying her way through so wrong!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Comment by tracy — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:09

  10. why the hell bother to have the public phone in when you have cheryl cole decide she wont follow the rules.its disgusting.if she had voted for 1 of her acts then it would of gone to deadlock and the public would of had a chance with there oppinion.

    Comment by karen — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:09

  11. What is the point? This reminds me of the Jedward debacle and the fixing that Simon Cowell seems indifferent to. Get some decent judges who are independent and, for at least two of them, some genuine experience that stands up to scrutiny. It makes a mockery of the money that thousands of genuine fans have spent on voting.

    Comment by KevinS — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:10

  12. Cheryl should not have been allowed to abstain. She should have had the last vote of the 4 judges and then should have taken it to deadlock if she could not decide.

    Katie was totally unprofessional. You do not say ‘sod it’ in the middle of a song and sit down.

    On the basis of being unprofessional, not one judge should have given her another chance.

    Simon only saved her for the publicity. It is quite clear that the viewers do not vote for her in sufficient quantities as this is the third time she has been in the bottom 3, so it is laughable to say that the viewers want to see her again next week. I certainly don’t.

    Comment by CarolynC — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:11

  13. My god……..yet another farcical show!!!!!!! Judges ‘grow some backbones’ the only one with any common sense and truisum is Danni…….require a sick bucket everytime Cringe Cheryl opens that simpering mouth of hers and gives out those insipid little girl lost transparant… ( Wy aye .. its all about me, the show is ) looks


    Comment by louise — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:11

  14. singing competition what a joke get new judges please b 4 next week MATT CARDLE 2 win go matt

    Comment by sandra — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:12

  15. the show is turning so stupid that it is only after silly show-makers rather than quality singers. Katie is so useless and sucks all your energy when you watch her. Get this stupid woman out of the show!

    Comment by Tsegi — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:12

  16. absolute farce, biggest con. Treyc is the better singer and does not bottle it constantly. How she has been voted out by the judges is beyond me and the whole nation I think

    Comment by Lala — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:13

  17. double standards…i thot xfactor was a singing talent show but it seems otherwise so i wont be watching anymore as well

    Comment by tunny — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:16

  18. Louis what a coward!! It is obvious that the judges have to follow the Cheryl line and make sure Cher & Katie get to the final. How come Cheryl can refuse to vote on one of her acts? It is sickening to see what she gets away with especially with the perv Cowell rubbing her back all through the show.

    Comment by anto — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:16

  19. I can not believe the decission of Simon and Louie tonight, seriously if the public wanted to see Katie back in why has she been in the bottom 2 for the past two weeks?! Iv been watching X factor since it very first started but NO longer will and shall be turning to the BBC to watch strictly, i might as well waste my time, watching something i dislike but at least is fair!!!

    Comment by Nicola Crawley — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:17

  20. wot a cock up! Cheryl said she’d let the other 2 vote and then take it to deadlock. If Treyc had got 3 votes then fair enough. It was supposed to go back to Cheryl to vote and she would have said Katie so it would go to deadlock. I’m sure the public vote would then have been for Katie to go..

    Comment by Caroline — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:19

  21. Why was Cheryl Cole not wearing a poppy?
    I find that insulting to the memory and sacrifices our forefathers and the troops currently serving this country make which enable her to make vast fortunes enjoyng the democracy which she seems so convenient to ignore. How shallow and ignorant.

    Comment by Chris P — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:19

  22. Does Cheryl Cole say anything other than “I’m so proud of you” or “I love you”.Surely her job is make constructive comments and not to stroke acts egos. Whatever her wage is I am sure she has to decide which acts to let go and those to keep….she didn’t earn her wage tonight and is becoming rather nondescript in the show. New judge please.

    Comment by Mark Black — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:20

  23. TreyC shouldn’t of gone home at all!! It should of been Katie, seeing as her sing off song was very very weak. How come someone who is in the bottom two so very many times is voted continously back into the show? The only judge who realised this was Dannii Minogue-but it wasn’t enough to save Treyc. It’s obvious that the public want her to go. I obviously don’t understand the format of the show anymore. Is it a singing competition or is it just a fix?
    Matt Cardle to win!!

    Comment by MB3 — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:22

  24. What a complete farce! Tonight’s show has confirmed that this is a fix! Paid £1Million a season and Cheryl can’t even make a decision but I bet she can take her pay check!
    Did Dermot jump the gun and make her decision for her? Absolutely disgusting.

    Comment by k ashby — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:22

  25. Get rid of Cheryl Cole, she is a drip. Cheryl Cole is becoming a bit of a light weight on X Factor.

    Comment by Sparks — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:23

  26. Louis what a coward!! It is obvious that the judges have to vote the way Cheryl dictates and that she wants Cher & Katie in the final. What a disgrace that Cheryl refused to vote.What would you expect when she allows pervert Cowell rub her back throughout the show. Country’s sweetheart my arse. Slapper yes

    Comment by anto — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:24

  27. absolutely discraceful they put katie through who not for the fist time forgets the words and clearly doesnt rehearse simons justification that katie was more watchable doesnt make sense when shes in the bottom 2 for the 3rd time and 2 weeks in a row..

    Comment by jack — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:26

  28. Complete fix for extra coverage of the programme. Treyc better singer and didnt mess it up, public has had katie in bottom two for three wks. They dont like her and want her gone! I’m fed up with this crap!!!

    Comment by Michelle mcgillick — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:27

  29. What an utterly spineless waste of rations that Geordie idiot is. She is paid to make a decision. If she lacks the courage to decide, get rid of her and send her back to Newcastle; Cole to Newcastle. Stay there you sub-human, pathetic wench

    Comment by Andy H — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:28

  30. Did they simply decide Cherly had forfeited the right to vote. It’s not her decision to make the rules so probably someone in the gallery said “sod her” and took away her ability to change the voting order.

    Katie deserved to go (not just for the unprofessional “sod it” but also for forgetting the words AGAIN!).

    Matt will probably win. Cher seems to have lost her sparkle, Rebecca will be huge anyway, Paige was great last night, Simon already has his boys signed up anyway (I would imagine), and is it wrong to wish Wagner could fall down the stairs before next week?

    Comment by Nick — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:28

  31. Cheryl refused to vote and said “ask the other two first and then I will send it to deadlock”. Several observations: 1) What made her think that it would end up in deadlock? and 2)Why didn’t the vote go back to Cheryl so she could send it to deadlock, letting the public decide? By refusing to vote, it appears that Cheryl was in effect responsible for Treyc’s eviction. So a question: how do I make an official complaint to ITV, since 1) the judging was unfair and broke the rules of the competiton and 2)I paid for a telephone vote which appears to have been ignored. Anyone out there know?

    Comment by janet — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:28

  32. That has got to be the biggest X-factor con, why was cheryl not allowed to dead lock the vote and let the public vote decide? Why did Dermot go to cheryl after simon? Normally she would be asked to cast her vote last. It stinks ITV should publish the voting numbers. Thats twice Katie has messed up her songs and got away with it.

    Comment by Del — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:30

  33. What a terrible injustice for Treyc, how can a judge abstain, if that had been one of the other judges it wouldn’t have been allowed, so Cheryl had two of her acts in the bottom 2 its the way the public voted its a singing contest not the cheryl Cole show, I think Cheryl should be banned from voting now.

    Comment by Jayne — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:30

  34. Cheryl Cole said she would let it go to dead lock so why was that not done and the one with the fewest votes would ha ve gone hopefully Katie.
    Katie fluffed her words (again) and still she is in along with the perv Wagner.

    Comment by Anne Taylor — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:31

  35. the only judge with backbone was danni minogue for sending home the right person who should have gone katie was a discrace who sits down and says sod it ..on national tv???? and she wants us to take her seriosly as a recording artist????..im sorry but she clearly cant be bothered to rehearse.. its a FIX !!! voting for style over substance…and not much styleat that

    Comment by phil — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:32

  36. I thought it was a singing contest not a drams queen contest Simons credability is slipping he likes Katie because she is different ye you got that right Simon she is dreadfull Treyc can sing is,nt that what x factor is all about

    Comment by pat — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:34

  37. The person with the least votes should go..How easy is that!!! Its making a mockery of the people who do phone in.

    Comment by cherchlechat — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:36

  38. O.M.F.G!! What the hell? Katie survives, AGAIN! Its not fair Treyc was by far better. Katie does this crap arse song, begging to be saved (pathetic) then crys like a bl**dy baby! WAAHHH, I can’t sing so I’ll cry and people will save me. For goodness sake, just quit the show. Louise was right, Danni was the only one to speck the truth. Why the judges voted for Katie I’ll never know, oh right shes a performer, (even though I never watch her) but if I buy her album (never gonna happen, I wouldn’t buy her single let alone her album, I’d rather shave my head paint it pink(hate that colour) and dree as a show girl and go on Britains Got Talent to express my undying love for Lord Voldemort (ewwwwww ‘shivers’ I’m gonna heva nightmares now)I wouldn’t be seeing her perform,I’d be LISTENING to her, I’d rather listen to nails on a chalk board. Girls like Katie make me sick. She was begging the judges, how low can she go?!

    The judges need to grow some sense because obviously they have NONE! I hated Jedward and now I hate Katie, Wagner (little bit of advice, sing in tune, sing the right words an- inface don’t sig at all!!) Aiden is pants too. I think Rebecca is GREAT! Same with Mary. They are my faves. This show has become a fix! I respect Simon Cowell but he was really wrong this time saving Crappie Katie. I say, MATT, MARY or REBECCA to WIN!! Katie to be booted out of the x factor!

    Oh and to Holly, hun I think Mary’s poppy was on her wrist, like a bracelet. But I do think that it should of been in a place where it could of been seen more.:)

    Comment by Becca — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:38

  39. Cheryl Cole is proper useless. At least the other three Judge and offer opinions. Get rid of Cole….she is the biggest waste of time on X Factor.


    Comment by Sarah — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:38

  40. Treyc is the best singer the competition has ever seen. I hope someone with some sense snaps her up so she can fulfill her potential. The judges are a joke. Get me on as a judge

    Comment by Siobhan — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:39

  41. Wrong decision. Trey C should have stayed, katie has been in the bottom two too many times, open you’re eyes judges what’s that tell you?! I’m getting fed up with katies emotional plees too stay face it she isn’t the publics 1st choice she needs too go and soo does Wagner, x factor is getting beyond a joke and I’ve given up on it.

    Comment by Jodie — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:43

  42. itv should be ashamed about showing this fix of a programme.she cocked up her first audition,she cocked up the judges house audition and she cocked up tonight and still survived.simon says treyc is not connecting with the public but katie is always in the sing off so she obviously don’t connect.cheryl cole thinks shes bigger than the programme and bent the rules and how can it be an american anthem week. they take the fucking piss.simon said he saved katie cos she is interesting!!!!! i bet wagner is interesting also but he cant sing so how is he different then katie

    Comment by gary — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:45

  43. I cannot believe it. Treyc has got better vocals than Katie 100 percent. Also Katie’s attitude is too “i don’t care sort of thing”but then she wants to be in there even though she does not give her best… Cheryl: “Did you not like Trayc?” why did you not help her??? it is not fair>>>>

    Comment by Jolie — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:49

  44. What totalk rubbish why was chryel cole not made vote it was totaly wrong tracy was professional while Katie just gave up it was not right

    Comment by Pat byrne — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:49

  45. Go danni has said the right name too send home soo good on you girl :) katie too go once and for all it’s what the public want. Fix or what!

    Comment by Jodie — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:56

  46. What a complete farce, its meant to be a singing competition katie forgot her words then had a bit of a breakdown and sat on the stage begging???? Cheryl said she would take it to dead lock, to me she has let treyc down big time she was one of the best singers in the so called singing competition. I will definatly not be watching this garbage anymore!!!!!!

    Comment by Mike — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:58

  47. Surely the public can’t accept this outcome. My wife is sat opposite me in our front room still going bonkers & making my ears bleed an hour later.

    Cheryl needs to be sacked for ruining my Sunday night in with my our lass. Booooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!!

    Comment by Deano — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 21:59

  48. I’d be quite happy to be a judge!!!!!!

    Comment by donna sargeant — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 22:01

  49. please, please, can they not get a couple of decent judges who can tell a good voice from a bad one,to take the place of simon and louie. simon did the same thing last year when lucy went instead of jedward.i think he must be tone deaf.the x factor is becoming a farce.

    Comment by david — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 22:05

  50. Excuse my last blogs crap punctuality but Cheryl’s done my head in. Everyone vote for Anne Widdicome instead. Boooooooooooo!

    Comment by Deano — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 22:05

  51. That was a travesty. The judges have in previous weeks gone on about this being a singing competition. But this week, Simon says ‘I will go with what i think the viewers want to see’. If the viewers wanted to see Katie she would get more votes. This should have been taken to deadlock and the decision made on viewers votes. I won’t be watching this trash any more.

    Comment by Bas — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 22:14

  52. cheryl was the nations sweetheart and i did like her as well.but tonight was out of order and she should not be allowed on the panel. i have watched since shayne won but will never watch again. cheryl should be sacked and for god sake do not give her a place on american x factor cos unlike us they will not stand for any of her crap. people should get their money back.

    Comment by margaret — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 22:14

  53. Katie was soooo aweful last night and tonight I was cringing, Cheryl definately said go to the others first then I’ll take it to deadlock-Dermott was very quick to say it was over. I thought surely this week Katie would go cos she was so bad

    make sure all that comment complain to ofcom https://stakeholders.ofcom.org.uk/tell-us/specific-programme-epg

    Comment by its a farce — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 22:29

  54. FIX, FIX, FIX!!!! Agree with all other comments!! Has X Factor turned into the Cheryl show??? everything seems to be all about her these days and she can’t even sing herself. Nations sweetheart I think not! more like Nations let down! Spoilt brat face Katie is so like her mentor! has anyone noticed Cheryl has pi**ed me off big time??? Get the scarecrow out we don’t want her there!!!! Arghhhhhh
    Treyc I am so hoping you go far and show off that fantastic voice of yours, i’ll buy your music for sure!!

    Comment by Rachel — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 22:35

  55. Cheryl is a disgrace, not only is she a rubbish judge but she actually does think this is HER show! The show is NOT about her and she should grow up! or resign ( thinking about it resigning is best ;0)

    Comment by Ad — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 22:37

  56. Why is there one rule for Cheryl Cole and one for everybody else nowadays? I used to think she was great but now think she’s a little mare! And if the contest’s about finding a recording star, why are they banging on about Katie being entertaining to watch? This is obviously a put-up job as however much she messes up – as she did from Day One – she gets thru.

    Comment by Marilyn Yurdan — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 22:38

  57. I’ve been following UK X factor from its beginnings (and am not from UK, greets from Italy:) and am completely gutted by what has happened tonight.

    What a set up, think I’ll no longer be watching it, too bad, you had international audience :) )

    Had respect for Simon, now he has disappointed me to the fullest.

    Don’t think Cheryl really makes the decisions by herself, not to mention, can’t she at least try some Recieved Pronunciation (not trying to be offensive, but for god’s sake, I can’t understand shit, haha).

    Ps. Matt Cardle to win!

    Comment by gabriella — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 22:55

  58. ps. my apologies for any typos/mistakes of any kind.

    Pps. Once again – Matt Cardle to win!

    And Cher isn’t all that.

    Comment by gabriella — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 22:57

  59. Erm, have I missed something here. Neither Treyce nor Katie should have been in the sing-off. The people who are voting to keep Wagner in the competition are the ones to blame. Yes, Cheryl was about as much good as a chocolate fire-guard when it came to the vote, but she should never have been put in that position in the first place.

    Comment by Jimbo — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 22:57

  60. absolutely diabolical farce from katie – my 8yr old daughter and 10 yr old son much better. she cant sing for toffee. she ought to be in the theatrics and not singing coz it just aint her thing…… ruined my sunday, monday, tuesday, wednesday, thursday, in fact the entire week, month and year!

    Comment by jackie — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 23:00

  61. I am totally disappointed with the judges decision especially Simon’s. I use to respect Simon’s views and comments believing he was fair, honest and based his decision and vote on the performers singing ability, but after tonight’s results for me, Simon’s credibility has totally gone down the drain.

    In the head to head sing off Katie forgot the words then sat on the floor and said ‘sod it’ on live t.v showing a total lack of professionalism. Were Simon and Louis watching a pre-recorded show on their monitors because they sure weren’t watching what was happening in front of them!

    I haven’t watched such nonsense in ages they are really taking the British public for mugs and at our expense. Yes, I took the time to vote unlike Cheryl.

    With two votes for Katie and one for Treyc, why did Dermott not return to Cheryl and push her for a vote. If she wanted to take it to deadlock then fair be it but she should have voted. I have already made a complaint to the ITV ombudsman.

    In the famous last words of MJ… ‘This is it’ I will NEVER watch Xfactor again. Utter crap

    Comment by Paula — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 23:02

  62. It’s a joke anyway when the public kept Wagner in who was singing completely off key for the first half of his act. It’s all a giant publicity stunt. A fix from start to finish.

    Comment by Sue — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 23:05

  63. Wrong decision why have judges if they refuse to make a decision should just let it go to bottom two every week and then deadlock danni is the only fair judge this year as she votes entirely on the sing of as the rules state pity the other judges don’t do the same x

    Comment by Anne mc — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 23:08

  64. What a farce. Dermot messed up yet no one has said anything about this. Normally the judges with the two acts in the bottom 2 are asked last. Dermot went straight to Cheryl. She said she would take it to deadlock yet this did not happen. Majority decision my butt. Make her vote. Dermot hold hands up and say you messed up. This is yet another example of TV programs disregarding public voting and fixing a result(Big Brother to mention just one. not watching anymore

    Comment by Ade — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 23:09

  65. I can’t believe that Tracey is gone!!
    The problem is that they made lots of mistakes> They had a chance to fix it but unfortunately they kept makings mistakes.
    1- He should not have askes Chelry Cole to vote in second as she has her 2 contestes in the bottom two, he allways ask last.
    2- She shoudl have voted (is her job) but at least she said she would send it to dead lock
    3- The judges voted to Tracey leave the competition, Simon alwals says that is a singing competion, so why they voted to Katey to stay as she is not professional, she has an good voice but nothing compared with Tracey, and she always forget the lyrics!!! So they voted wrong!
    4- And after all those mistakes theu didn’t go back to Cherly then she could go for deadelock!!

    I really do not understand what is happening. I am a big fa of the program but after today i am staring to believe what people say, that this program is fix!! They probable already know who is gonna win!!! Is not fair, because people spend their money voting!!!

    Comment by Vanessa Sotto — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 23:12

  66. Apparently the show’s producers are now coming out with some crap about it being “a majority vote”. The trouble is that even if Cheryl had not broken the rules of the competition by refusing to vote, she had already stated that she intended sending it to deadlock. So how do we know what effect this had on Louis’ voting decision? I have just made a complaint to Ofcom (you can do it online) on the basis that viewers have paid for votes which, ultimately, were ignored in total contradiction of the competition’s own rules. PS Agree with above – Katie is behaving like she has snakes coming out of her head (instead of a bleached brillo pad).

    Comment by janet — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 23:13

  67. whats wrong with Simon if the public wanted to see her do you not think they would have voted for her..?!!! Katie has forgotten her words 2/3 times and has been in the bottom two 3 times!! katie and wagner to go!

    MATT TO WIN!!!

    Comment by Kathy — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 23:15

  68. OMG…….. poor Cheryl she said to Dermot that she wanted to vote last so she could take it to deadlock but he didn’t listen to her they sent Katie through when really they should have sent it to deadlock and Treyc would have gone through for definite and why the f**k is WAGNER still in he really does p**s me off i am backing CHER LLOYD and ONE DIRECTION all the way i love love love them :) xxxx

    Comment by Kirsty Thompson, Skegness — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 23:23

  69. I agree totally with all the above comments. Treyc never had a shot in this show with Cheryl has a mentor (don’t make me laugh). Look back to the judges homes. Treyc was told NO from the start by Cheryl. Only because of the wildcard did she get a shot. Cheryl is getting paid big bucks to participate in the show and doesn’t vote. WHAT IS THAT ALL ABOUT. If she lost some of her dosh for not voting I’m sure she will change her mind. Completely unfair voting for Treyc she never stood a chance against the two girls who COULDN’T PERFORM in the Judges homes. I agree Katie didn’t sing her surival song she begged her way through it. As for Louie his heart says one thing and the head another. Surely his head should have been saying Treyc could make us money. If Katie gets to the final. NO MORE X-FACTOR IT IS JUST A FIX.

    Comment by Brenda — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 23:32

  70. cheryl didn’t take it to deadlock ’cause kate who had messed-up her song had 2 votes. she never wanted treyc at all. i am now switching on to strictly come dance.

    Comment by fawz — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 23:59

  71. who cares who stays who goes its all a load of crud anyhow only muppets watch this drivvel and even bigger plebs vote hahaha get a life ffs

    Comment by vagner von shyte — Sunday, 7 November, 2010 @ 23:59

  72. i stil can’t belive this happened on live tv

    Comment by fawz — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 00:03

  73. I’m disgusted with the judges this week, if the public like that Katie then she wouldn’t end up in the bottom two almost every week… Treyc was the better singer and shouldn’t have been sent home.

    Cheryl said she wanted to take it to deadlock after the other judges voted and then it would rely on the public vote which I am confident would have said goodbye to Katie…. X Factor has lost a viewer I won’t be watching again its farce.

    Comment by Jayde — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 00:26

  74. Go Dannii, the only judge on the panel i agree with tonite, the rest of them were a joke!!! Katie should’ve been gone long ago, she forgets the words and sits there like a snivelling child and then gets saved by the judges – pathetic, I’ll be boycotting this show from now on what happened tonite shouldn’t have been allowed!! Simon had to vote when it was 2 of his acts in the bottom 2 so what makes Cheryl Cole so bloody special, ok she said she would take it to deadlock but that never happened, Treyc didn’t deserve what happened, Katie is rotten on all levels.

    Comment by MIchelle — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 00:38

  75. I am quite surprised that the judges have decided to go again with Katie even though she doesn’t deserve it…I’m so disappointed that the one with talent had to leave….I guess I would have to start to vote for Wagner just to teach those judges a lesson especially Cheryl….And what this stupid praising that Simon is doing for Cheryl about her single reaching number one and stuff….I wonder which chart they took that from coz it’s Rihanna single Only Girl (in the world) that is number one this week….Gosh….I feel so disgusted with Cheryl….

    Comment by Marie — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 01:42

  76. this is bullshit its obviously all a fix katie should have went home what a disgrace

    Comment by lydia — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 01:46

  77. if cheryl didnt vote anyone why didnt it go to the viewers votes? There were two for treyc and one for katie, that makes it deadlock. Please someone answer that. Also I am ashamed of Simon for saying that he went for the viewers opinion. What?!?!? Take a look at what the viewers are REALLY SAYING SIMON!!! It needs to be sorted out. That was totally wrong wrong wrong!!!!!

    Comment by linda — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 06:06

  78. do people really wanna see a popstar 2 say “sod it” & sit down in the middle of the song?? i don’t think so simon i thought u were a good judge maybe not now katie was CRAP!!!!!!!!!! x factor is all about the judges not singers wat a complete joke!!!!

    Comment by tracy — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 07:16

  79. Why are you people bashing Cheryl? It was hard to chose for her since both girls are under her mentoring, its like asking her which children she love more.

    What she did was completely normal which is voting last, to push it to dead lock and letting the fans choose instead.

    What’s deplorable is the production who knew damn well that Katie would be out so they changed the rules. To keep her.

    And btw, what the **** is Simon and Louis thinking? I wonder what Katie did to those two to make them vote for her. Unprofessional, terrible singer, they should know better. What a disgrace.

    I think X-Factor just shoot themselves in the foot and lost a tons of fans and credibility.

    Comment by Stradale — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 08:19

  80. Thought it was a singing contest.CLEARLY NOT!. Love you lots Simon but you definately got it wrong this time. Big time!!!!!!!!!

    Comment by Alia — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 08:36

  81. Absolute rubbish last night – Katie made a fool of herself-she looked a mess from the start-she could not remember her words-yet again – has no special voice it is very mediocre. A total wreck-no dignity- she made me cringe. Treyc who conducted herself with dignity and could sing, was voted out, are some of the judges deaf,blind,or just stupid. I enjoy X Factor and enjoy watching people progress through the weeks – not this time Katie has gone backwards yet they still vote her i n as with others WHY!!!! it makes no sense

    Comment by Vivien — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 08:39

  82. Last night result confirms everybody’s suspicions that the xfactor is a fix.Of course Simon wanted to protect the investment he made in buying Katie out of her record deal to make more money from her as she got the most votes!!!!

    Cheryl Cole is a joke.First the Gamu decision now the Treyc decision Cheryl grow a pair.Just because they were better singer does not mean they are threat to you.

    A message to the judge’s aside from Danni who amazingly got it right,You are a disgrace swindeling the public out of money so they will vote again in their droves to express their opinion as to who has talent and who does not.The sing off is a fore gone conclusion last night as an example so why bother putting the contestants or the public through that.X Factor is a FIX!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Comment by ross — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 08:49

  83. what a joke,katie should have gone home.she cannot sing .treyc is a much better singer.(IT IS A SINGING COMP IS IT NOT!!!)the whole programe is a fix.i wont be watching again.WHY DOESNT EVERYONE MAKE A STAND AND BOYCOTT THE PROGRAME NEXT WEEKEND.COME ON WHOS WITH ME.

    Comment by andrew jones — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 09:01

  84. Greetings from France! So disappointed by the results, even watching the way katie starts mouthing I’m sorry to treyc just after Simons verdict It’s obvious that Katie knows she’s going to win, It’s all been a fix from the start but that really gave it away big time!
    I’ve got a feeling this could turn out really nasty a lot of fans are upset and i think that the audience could very well boo Katie right off stage next week or even do a walk out or stand up but turn there backs the other way in protest. Other people are saying they won’t be watching anymore so it will hurt cowell where it hurts the most ….. in his wallet.

    Comment by Marie — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 09:08

  85. I would like to know how many votes Katie and Treyc received. Disgusted, wrong decision AGAIN! sack the judges, and put ordinary people in their places! If ITV are stupid enough to make another series (God help us) please rename it “The B@!!@X Factor!”

    Comment by David — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 09:17

  86. Cheryl Cole should be banned from judging any future acts in the bottom two for the remainder of the show. As said by previous contributors it is obvious that Cowell is protecting his investment in Katie. Her having a contract in America broke the rules so it was simply bought out.
    I’m sure Mrs Cole or Tweed, depending on the time of day, is a very happy bunny this morning!!

    Comment by anto — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 09:27

  87. Absolutely disgusted by last nights decision…. Cheryl’s job is to vote for someone to go out… The other judges have had to do it in the past… If she was still refusing then it should have gone to deadlock and the public’s vote should have been the decider!! I think they just wanted Treyc out and made up their own rules.. Based on that performance Treyc was clearly the one who should have stayed.. How many times is someone going to be allowed to forget their words and have a meltdown live on stage before they get rid of them! – Rant over!! lol

    Comment by Zoe — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 10:06

  88. What a farce…. Is everyone scared of Cheryl because Simon likes her? Dermot should not have caved in so easily. Cheryl should have been forced to vote or it should have been taken to the public vote. We are all fed up with Katie, so why should she stay in? She sang out of tune and Treyc didn’t. Simon isn’t even Mr Nasty anymore. He says the same thing every week now.

    Comment by kathy — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 10:09

  89. I do so agree with all the adverse comments and would certainly look for a dismissal of the non talented Cheryl Cole,an apology to all the viewers, a refund of all calls made to the studios which are obviously meaningless just another way of adding income and an inquiry by the ombudsman. They have to replace Cheryl Cole next week. Louie is always quick to point out the rule book, why did he not do it to Cheryl Cole and Simon Cowell on this occassion? What a waste of time and space it all wins. Matt had better win he has the Nations heart and HE CAN SING. or is it now the Cheryl Cole show?

    Comment by terry green — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 10:33

  90. Should be called the Y factor. Y bother voting, Y bother with a sing off, Y bother watching. If the public votes do count then Wagner will win as the nation is so fed up with the hypocritical judges (Danni excepted) that they’re voting for Wagner to show that the programme has become a joke. No longer a credible singing competition now just another soap where they cast characters to play a part. Script has probably already been written for rest of this series.

    Comment by Wagner — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 10:39

  91. What an absolute travesty, its no wonder people think the show is a fix. Cheryl said she’d vote after the others and take it to deadlock (did she know how the others were going to vote I ask myself), but then wasn’t given the chance, so Treyc was unfairly sent home surely. It would be interesting to know who the public actually put in last place. Do they actually want to lose viewers, it does seem like it!!!!

    Comment by Jackie — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 11:15

  92. I never thought I’d add my comments to a blog, but what a fix, fix, false, fix rubbish. Sick of the X factor being about Cheryl and Simon, it should be about singers and who the people want, not the tripe we have seen recently.

    Comment by James — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 11:18

  93. I feel Simon,Cheryl and Louie should apologize to Treyc,the audience & the public….last night the judges clearly voted unfairly,disgraceful & embarrassing to watch & listen to them.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Comment by Sharon — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 11:18

  94. The xfactor is all about Cheryl.She is not bothered about who win the competition as long as she can get her weekly publicity out of it.Think about it.why would she go off to America leaving he girls.

    Comment by Santos — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 12:12

  95. Absolute farce!!! Katie is awful singer and a mess to look at. She should never have been picked for final in first place and she is obviously unpopular with the public!!
    Cheryl creates her own rules and should have been made to vote. She would be terrified to go to public vote as katie would have been bottom. Every year the whole show gets more and more farcical with the judges making rules as they go along.Best judge without a doubt is Danni as I agree with everything she says about the contestants.
    Matt and Rebecca are a class well above the others although Aiden is pretty strong too.

    Comment by susan logan — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 12:17

  96. Treyc Cohen should not have been voted off. It was a travesty to keep Katie Waisell in. Danni was the only one have the guts to vote Katie off, the other two judges seem to always side with Cheryl Cole, who gets paid to judge then ops out when it suits her. She never has promoted or given any good comments about Treyc – also am I the only one who thinks Cheryl Cole cannot sing, and I mean sing, not shout as she does. May either Aiden, Mary or Matt win, the only real talent in the show, if you can call it a show!

    Comment by Evelyn Curtis — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 12:17

  97. 72 comments not one supporting Katie, Cheryl defiantly said come back to me to make it a deadlock. Katie would have lost by a landslide in the public vote, they all knew this Very WRONG

    Comment by rodney — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 12:23

  98. I made a further comment on this blog last night which doesn’t seem to have got posted … Just to say I have complained to Ofcom (which you can do online) on the basis that veiwers paid for votes which were not taken into account in the final vote, as per the rules of the competition. Will keep you posted – hopefully!

    Comment by janet — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 12:33

  99. Cheryl should be performing on Xfactor.She has no talent for singing.She was carried on the backs of the other girls from her band. and now she is begining to beleive her own publicity what a connnnn.

    Comment by salva — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 12:45

  100. 2 words… A DISGRACE.
    cheryl refusing to vote this week?? she should be booted off the show, if she had sent to tiebreak then the result would sure have been different as katie is rubbish.who does cheryl think she is, clearly believing the over hype that its now the cowell and cole show. and last week not performing live 2 the nation, she is commenting on performers who are at least can sing live.
    This show is a complete farce and fix, I hope Wagner wins and surely it will mean the end of this crap show made even worse when that geordie bird joined and Mrs O left
    Here endeth the lesson!!!

    Comment by chris — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 15:04

  101. What a complete travesty that Treyc who sang flawlessly was voted off and Katie, whose performance was a shambolic mess, was kept in.
    As with the Jedward/Lucie debacle last year it’s painfully obvious that all Simon is interested in is publicity, not singing talent.
    I thought the judges had to base their decision as to who to send home on the final sing off alone, as otherwise what’s the point of even having a sing off?
    Once again, like last year, Danni appears to be the only judge with any integrity there, Louis and Cheryl are just Simon’s puppets. So is Dermot come to think of it as he should have gone back to Cheryl and got her take it to deadlock.

    Comment by Martha — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 15:08

  102. what point is the public vote if it is not used Cheryl Cole said “i will vote when the others have voted and then go to the public vote” so what happend? also singing competition not drama queen competition simon cowel whats up with you, to preocupied with the new us show what is it sc*w the uk now, treyc sang her song katie did not any other act would have gone. next week katie can stand on stage and not sing a note she will still stay why bother paying for a phone call this is bordering on fraud pay for your call we will ignore it i think the only way this will be sorted is by releasing the public vote. one more thing there is only 1 judge who is true to the competition and that is danni

    Comment by paul — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 15:51

  103. please, how this talent scout let the good singer go, is ther any favoritsm her,or money is talking,im not watching xfactor anymore.

    Comment by menc — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 16:07

  104. no 64, dermot didn’t screw up he always goes to the judges with acts in the bottom 2 first and also when cheryl said she wud send it to deadlock dermot said if she didn’t vote then it wud mean she was forfeiting her vote

    Comment by jenny — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 16:27

  105. if there was a show of who the biggest babies r katie would win & cher would b second bloody cry babies, i think the judges should look back at wat they done, so wrong wat a waste of time x factor is now!!! i feel sorry 4 the 1′s who can sing matt will win unless katie crys her way 2 the final!!!!!

    Comment by tracy — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 17:29

  106. This Show STINKS I wont be watching ever again. Treyc was swindled out of a place on the show. Simon Cowl is a conman. Where can viewers complain ? this FRAUD needs investigating. Why are we PAYING for telephone votes so they can FIX the results!!!

    Comment by Joan — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 18:23

  107. Thats it then, spread it around evrywhere, put it on all the bulletin boards and forums. ALL VOTE FOR WAGNER, and lets make a killing at the bookies

    Comment by rodney — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 18:45

  108. Serve them all right if nobody voted from now on as they don’t give a damn about what the audience thinks. Maybe they should go straight to the end of the contest and give Katie the contract if they think she’s that bloody wonderful, and stop wasting everybody elses’s time.

    Comment by Marilyn Yurdan — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 18:45

  109. What a joke last night, i think i remember the program blue peter having to refund the cost of a phone call to thousands when a competition was fixed, so what about all the people who voted for Treyc ( if it went to the public vote she could have won ) their calls counted for nothing, when she needed them most. will not watch again.

    Comment by phil — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 22:17

  110. I laughed last night. My wife loves X Factor and even she thought Cheryl Cole was a div. How can someone who mimes her own songs on the show she’s a panellist be taken seriously. I have no doubt Simon Cowell will say something crawly and creepy to the public next Saturday. Cheryl Cole’s days must be numbered, she’s a farce. She supposedly earns £500k per year from X Factor, last nights showing was worth 500 pence. Goodbye Cheryl Cole….please leave X Factor and join X Files.

    Comment by mark — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 22:59

  111. You’ve got to admire X Factor. They want to keep a singer who swears mid song and forgets her words. Show has become a joke, and Cheryl Cole is the biggest joke of all. I have no doubt Katie will be fantastic this week and they’ll all fawn over her. DO NOT VOTE FOR KATIE. VOTE FOR WAGNER.

    Comment by sparks — Monday, 8 November, 2010 @ 23:06

  112. What a complete farce this X Factor has become ! Cheryl Cole is doing her best for one of her favourites to win (namely Cher or the detestable Weasel} What about Rebecca ? She seems to ignore her, just like she did with TrayC. Shame she’s ignored the talent and chosen to go with the ‘novelty’ acts. Shame on her. She should be replaced by a better, honest judge next year – IF the show survives !!

    Comment by Bonny — Tuesday, 9 November, 2010 @ 00:10

  113. Simon Cowell. If this show is your creation, get a decent judge ! Time Cheryl went, just like her two lap dogs – Cher and the Weasel ! Dani is great and Louis is a welcome laugh. The Pussycat doll was a fantastic, refreshing judge. Let her be Cheryl’s replacement !

    Comment by CK — Tuesday, 9 November, 2010 @ 00:18

  114. It was 100% wrong to expect Cheryl to vote before the others. Just think – if the one she voted for got to stay how could they have worked together afterwards?
    It has to be that the mentor of both in bottom two goes last so that either the majority settles it first or that mentor can take it to public vote.
    How on earth could the managers of X-factor not have understood and established that by now. It was an appalling to dilemma to land Cheryl with and she was right to ask to go last.
    Dermot I guess was only doing as he was told – the producers are the ones who got this so wrong in the first place.
    Then of course Simon and Louis really ruined it by breaking the rules themselves and not voting according to the final performances. Especially since those performances typified the two contestants. Katie is a weak performer and far too immature, at least at present; Treyc is an excellent singer. Choosing between them should have been simple – you only had to look at Katie to see that’s what she expected as well.
    As for allowing a non-singer to continue – it’s beyond all understanding – who would buy records of Wagner? Certainly not anyone who wants to listen to singing.

    Comment by Theresa — Tuesday, 9 November, 2010 @ 08:36

  115. the x-factor show saturday was a complete farce and a joke and they change the rules to suit themselves. Cheryl should have been made to vote, thus taking it to deadlock and therefore going to public vote.Which i’m sure the public would have voted for Katie to go.So Cheryl has actually sent trayc home not anyone else.the show is a joke now and the voying system should be changed especially if there a campaign for Wagner to win because he really really cannot sing.he should not even be on the show.be interesting to see who did get lowest public vote because if it was Katie then they will have to bring trayc back and send katie home as its the right thing to do

    Comment by jo — Tuesday, 9 November, 2010 @ 09:09

  116. Its becoming a farce when a brilliant singer like Trayc is sent home and rubbish like Wagner are still there.
    Which idiots are voting for him?
    People are gonna stop watching if something doesn’t change.

    Comment by Sue foster — Tuesday, 9 November, 2010 @ 09:25

  117. Well one of my 3 went!! I wanted Wagner, Katie or Treyc out. Treyc bores the hell out of me. BUT this time, this bottom 2, it should have been Katie. Very unprofessional of her!!!!
    Judges with 2 acts in the bottom should be made to vote last – where they can send it to deadlock if the other 3 judges haven’t all kicked out the same person.

    Comment by Sara — Tuesday, 9 November, 2010 @ 10:15

  118. the only judge who know’s what they are doing is Dani. I feel so sorry for her because Simon and Cheryl leave her out and act like the 2 sniggering bullies at school!!

    Katie should have gone. the show should be called THE FIX FACTOR

    Comment by melissa — Tuesday, 9 November, 2010 @ 10:46

  119. Wont waste money on votes. they don’t count, was a joke on Saturday night.

    Comment by mena — Tuesday, 9 November, 2010 @ 10:54

  120. Theresa i think you have it wrong cheryl said she would take it to deadlock she didnt even have to chose louis did the same in a previous season dermot discounted her vote she clearly said ask the others first and i will take it to deadlock it must go to deadlock according to the rules or else why pay to vote its not treyc who has been mistreated its the public and the right to be heard how many millions of pounds went to vote you may as well done the lottery at least your pound counts for somthing

    Comment by paul — Tuesday, 9 November, 2010 @ 12:51

  121. I agree with all the comments 100%!!! What a fix, Katie is so untalented and immature, how can she be there if she was in a bottom two three times? What a joke u’re judges apart from Dannie, i would not like to see Katie anymore singing, it’s crap!!! The only judge i respect now is Dannie, hope Matt will win! Even Treyc has unfairly gone she is the winner not stupid crying blonde girl! Shame on you!!!

    Comment by Tati — Tuesday, 9 November, 2010 @ 13:40

  122. what is the point of judges, if they do not actually cast a vote………..l thought it was totally unfair……..this competetion is not judged on talent……..someone who forgets who words and swears on stage does not warrant being voted in…..I think a lot of people were disapointed with the show, and the result. good luck to Tracy she was so graceful when told she had to leave.

    Comment by aj — Tuesday, 9 November, 2010 @ 17:43

  123. That says it all, a lot of people think the X factor is a load of CRAP! Now let’s tell the truth about ‘Strictly come dancing’ Also, I would like to see “squeaky-clean” Ray Quinn on “celebrity jungle get me out of here”

    Comment by David — Tuesday, 9 November, 2010 @ 19:00

  124. THE RIGHT THING TO DO NOW IS – NO VOTE!! Stop wasting your money calling to vote it is not gonna change anything the show ia fix!!! And I’m sure they will not do anything about it because what matters to them is the money they earn from the calls! The best thing to do is stop calling and voting! DO NOT VOTE ANYMORE!!

    Comment by Vanessa Sotto — Tuesday, 9 November, 2010 @ 19:36

  125. Well according to today’s newspapers, Katie only got one third of the public votes that Treyc got. In other words, Treyc wuz robbed! Under the circs, you can’t really blame pissed off viewers for voting for the awful Wagner …

    Comment by janet — Wednesday, 10 November, 2010 @ 00:38

  126. Is there a fundamental failing in this show in that the judges are mentors too? How can they possibly judge fairky when they are also trying to win with their own acts?
    I have wondered about this for some time and the latest travesty seems to me to confirm it.

    Comment by Theresa — Wednesday, 10 November, 2010 @ 08:22

  127. Cheryi Cole must follow the rules of X-Factor. It is farsical Simon Cowell is allowing the show to be a joke.
    Katie should have been booted out. I will not be watching X-Factor again. Danni is the only judge who is fair. Louise comes out with some tripe every now and then. The public should stop funding by not calling the very expensive line with their votes. ITV– SHAME ON YOU.

    Comment by reta — Wednesday, 10 November, 2010 @ 20:37

  128. X Factor is turning into a joke. The comments by Simon about Katie being more appealing to the viewing audience because she acts like a diva and gets more press, was not only disrespectful to Trecy, who is by far a more talented singer than Katie but it was insulting to large number of viewers that watch the show. We expect impartial judging, which is the crock of the shows appeal. Simon and Cheryl showed a lack of integrity, that I think if they are not careful, could be their on doing.

    Comment by Kemi — Wednesday, 10 November, 2010 @ 21:12

  129. I think it’s time for a new panel this lot clearly have no idea the amount of bad publicity that Katie has been getting she has been in the bottom 3 times and Simon thinks she is more appealing to the public is he having a laugh however I think Simon is very clever as the longer Katie stays in the more people kick up a fuss and X Factor keeps getting the all the publicity.

    One Direction or Matt to win love them both xxx

    Comment by Cheryl Fitzsimmons — Thursday, 11 November, 2010 @ 10:21

  130. X-Factor is a farce. Cheryl Cole thinks its a gravy train for her benefit. Cheryl Cole should have voted and not allowed to abstain. Opportunities for Cheryl should be nipped in the bud in USA as she is shallow and fickle. Public should stop voting. ITV must be taught a lesson that the voting public cannot be ignored

    Comment by reta — Thursday, 11 November, 2010 @ 12:47

  131. I totally agree with many of the comments above, the fact Simon said that he will judge on performance is very hypochritcal as when his favourites mess up he cant face it. They have showed truly unprofessional behaviour especially Cheryl by showing their favouritism. What I dont get is why the British Public keep putting cheryl on a pedestal? Yes shes pretty but if you had the money she had anyone can get their teeth, hair extensions and complete facial overhaul done, nora batty would look like a queen with her dosh. I dont have anything personal against Cheryl but lets be honest she cant sing but looks good? is this what the public is teaching young people just look pretty forget talent, its insulting to have someone like her judging talented people when she cant even sing live, the public should wise up and stop with this rubbish nations sweetheart? what the hell has she done to be a sweetheart, help people? no beat up toilet attendants and not apologise, the public should not put this money making idiot on a pededstal, louis was right when he said the show is not about her?? Simon has her like a little token, its embarassing and I expect more of him but hes shown how shallow he is,ive lost any respect for him.

    Comment by Richard Simpson — Thursday, 11 November, 2010 @ 20:43

  132. To say that one person is not as interesting as another is quite insulting when you dont really know that person. Last week with the Weasel and Treyc dilemma, Simon needs to look at what hes really saying, is being interesting and more entertaining having a hissy fit on stage and wearing freaky hair, having dramas and fake tears every 5 mins? Well I dont find that interesting and best left for the acting profession I would say rather than singing. I used to watch x factor for singing, for someone that could sing the best, that I could listen to their record and hear an amazing voice, I dont watch it for these over rated egos like Katie weasel or cher over arrogant, instead Simon crushes true entertainers dream by telling them singing is not enough, in this case acting like a jackass pays off? how crazy this show has become, The judges fix it all and havent covered that very well which is really unprofessional and insulting to the true artists on the show. When you buy a record, you hear a voice, you dont need to know if that person has blue, pink or green hair, music should have no colour or prejudice, hes just made it something that is prejudicied by choosing a preferance of what he finds interesting over good vocals, disgraceful.

    Comment by Linda Mary — Thursday, 11 November, 2010 @ 20:49

  133. What can I say? Simon is engineering cheryls career (god knows why) I always knew he liked a pretty face but thought he could see through talentless people and appreciated true talent? Obviously him getting old has made his mind go a bit nuts, everything Cheryls weak acts do are fantastic?, Rebecca is more talented than the other two but they keep telling them how great they are?? Cheryl Cole got her big break when Ashley cheated, the publicity did her no harm in fact boosted her career so a thank you to ashley she should give, also all these fake crocodile tears about her time with him, he was a footballer? she knew what the life might be like, its sad about the x factor, they have made a joke of a show i used to like but hey money is more important to simon and his cronies, not even the contesants or public matter? Its all about the money they bring in, thats why these shock decision are done every week so they get all the exposure and in turn more money? its a waste of the voters money, if its about entertainment then everyone should vote Wagner, Katies no better so why not vote wagner, they laugh at him but how different is he from the thunderbird gargoyle cher and the weasel attention seeking wassel?? wagner might as well win, hes just following suit with the act line up. True artists should now think twice about entering the x factor and its not about true talent anymore its about fake personalities that can barely sing, simon wants over eccentric divas, so we have a new breed of artist that is arrogant, OTT, selfish and conceited, thats what he wants, great example for kids hey?

    Comment by Mark Eastmond — Thursday, 11 November, 2010 @ 20:58

  134. Its a disgrace that aiden is gone what a fantastic singer.. shame on u Simon!!

    Comment by NICOLA CARROLL — Monday, 15 November, 2010 @ 09:20

  135. what a joke! He is far better than katie he was on of my favs! Katie has meen in the bottom to and they still keep putting ehr though it is a waste of outr time and the judges time to!!! Kaite is a rubish singer and should not be getting saved all the time !! It would be better for all of us if she just stopted it she has a rubish voice some one like one directiong or matt should be going though !!! PLESE LET HER GO OUT NEXT WEEK !!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Comment by grace potter — Monday, 15 November, 2010 @ 20:34

RSS feed for comments on this post. | TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

XHTML ( You can use these tags): <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> .