Comments on: Joe McElderry X Factor 2009 Winner

By: Courteney

Courteney — Tue, 30 Nov 2010 18:21:01 +0000

All of you have different people you like but you cannot say that when same difference was on the show they were not entertaining.
The public voted
its what the show is about.
so if you dont like it dont blame it on the judges or the person that won the x factor stop being so ridiculous and grow up. obviously the last 2 acts in the show are good singers and have the audiences attention but whoever wins, they both always seem to get sighnes such as alexandra burke and JLS, Olly murs and Joe mcelderry.

By: louis

louis — Fri, 22 Jan 2010 22:01:19 +0000

on the final day it was stacey olly joe go frew stacey olly the is stacey no it is not joe is and i thick that joe rocks a little bit and on tv i cud see you and cherl were shing to win!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

By: chloe wilson and lauren

chloe wilson and lauren — Sun, 20 Dec 2009 11:20:15 +0000

omg joe your good but olly shoud of won :):):):):):):):):):):):):):)

By: Lauren

Lauren — Sun, 20 Dec 2009 11:05:30 +0000

Nice one joe. You rock. I love you ! x

By: Dani

Dani — Wed, 16 Dec 2009 21:06:13 +0000

OMG what is wrong wif u people!!! olly should have won do we really need another boring singer? anyone who didnt vote for olly after his performances on the final are just idiots!! joe should have came second yeah he is a gd singer buts thats as far as it goes.. ad much rather buy ollys album than joes!!!

By: Eddie

Eddie — Wed, 16 Dec 2009 15:38:44 +0000

Lets be honest none of the finalists have really lost,OK Joe has been crowned overall winner with the Guaranteed recording contract but last season only two acts have made there way into the charts last years winner Alexandra Burke of course and JLS but this years show could produce at least five new acts to the charts from the list of finalist,Lucie Jones, Jamie Archer, Lloyd Daniels, John and Edward Grimes, Stacey Solomon, Danyl Johnson, Olly Murs are in the money already the Twins are undoubtedly on the road to some other form of fame other than singing and good luck to them I think this years X Factor to be the best yet.

By: James

James — Tue, 15 Dec 2009 00:06:42 +0000

Theresa, Peter is right. Only Jedward who were the worst of the acts which could not sing created any real spark with the viewers and the Media.

The fact that Jedward will probably be the most successful act from X Factor 2009 shows that it completely failed as a singing competition.

By: Violet

Violet — Tue, 15 Dec 2009 00:03:28 +0000

Theresa (6)

You are either trying to be controversial or need to concentrate more.

Peter is clearly saying that the X Factor needs to find real singing talent for 2010 because the people who could sing in X Factor 2009 were bland and did not display the spark that is needed to show that you have the X Factor.

He is being ironic when he says that Jedward who could not sing were entertaining. The other acts including those that could hold a tune were boring.No one had the X Factor.

Hopefully this has helped you to understand Peter’s comments.

By: Peter

Peter — Mon, 14 Dec 2009 23:53:42 +0000

Theresa,

I have not contradicted myself at all. The people who could sing had no charisma and certainly did not have the X Factor – they were boring. Most people I have talked to in the music profession have said that this was probably the worst X Factor so far for singing talent.Just because people can sing does not mean they have real talent.

Leona Lewis and Alexandra had the X factor.They have real talent. They are not boring. Simon Cowell desperately needs to find the same level of singing talent for 2010.

The general consensus about X Factor 2009 is that no one had the X Factor and it was only Jedward that created any kind of excitement and debate.

To correct you on another point Jedward were not the only act in the Final Twelve who could not sing. You are forgetting Kandy Rain, two members of Miss Frank, Lloyd Daniels and Rikki Loney. Of the others Lucie, Jamie, Olly,Stacey and Danyl had trouble with tuning a number of times. Rachel and Joe were the only two that were able to constantly hold a tune. Rachel made a swift exit and Joe’s voice is not unique and is far too bland.

To help you understand why I want X Factor to finish if they cannot find some real singing talent for 2010 is that 2009 did have people could sing but they were not talented. I hope this clarifies my statement for you.

To have a singing competiton of merit you need talented singers. If you thought there was real singing talent in X Factor 2009 there are a lot of people especially music professionals who would disagree with you.

By: Olly Fan

Olly Fan — Mon, 14 Dec 2009 21:48:18 +0000

I was so angry last night when joe won. Olly sang that song the way it was so suppose to sound.

Do we really need another pretty boy who can hold a few notes at a time, eh no not really.

He also killed one of the best journey songs of all time. Mabey Olly should of sang it at least then you would actually feel emotion. Not Feeling it with joe.

Too up himself like his mentor.