» Audition for the X Factor 2009! «

Monday, 29 September, 2008

X Factor 2008 - Final 12 Revealed?

Sources close to one of the final 12 have delivered us what appears to be a list of all the finalists through to the live shows. It should be noted that official X Factor sources have neither confirmed or denied this list - but it looks pretty accurate to us.

What do you think - is this list correct? Are there other acts that should have gone through? Post your comments below.

Girls - Cheryl Cole

Diana Vickers
Alexandra Burke
Laura White

Boys - Simon Cowell

Scott Bruton
Eoghan Quigg
Austin Drage

25 and Overs - Dannii Minogue

Rachel Hylton
Danny Evans
Suzie Furlonger

Groups - Louis Walsh

Bad Lashes
GirlBand
JLS

102 Comments »

  1. I can not believe Rachel Hylton got through,
    She is so rude and not fit to win / be in the final 12 contestants.
    There were other equally good contestants

    Myself and my friends are not going to waste our votes until she is out!

    Comment by eiden — Monday, 29 September, 2008 @ 10:34

  2. Rachel may be raw but her talent is undeniable.

    Comment by rachel — Monday, 29 September, 2008 @ 16:19

  3. I can not believe that Joelle Moses is out, How on earth did the judges come to that conclusion? absurd I tell you.
    What were they thinking off?

    All I can say, do it on your own Joelle, Who knows, you could be bigger than Leona Lewis, just believe in yourself, if you are hungry enough, you will make it.

    There is a lot of people out there, who knows your potential.

    Comment by Theo — Monday, 29 September, 2008 @ 21:37

  4. I know Diana Vickers has got through as they’ve been filming at our school…..

    Comment by fairy Cake — Tuesday, 30 September, 2008 @ 09:42

  5. How did Amy Connelly not get through, shes amazing i love her. Alan turner and ruth lorenzo were well good aswell !

    Comment by Gary — Tuesday, 30 September, 2008 @ 22:34

  6. GO EOGHANNNNNNNNNNNNN!

    WE ALL WANT YOU TO WIN!!!!! =)

    LOVE YOU PILESS =D

    xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

    Comment by muffin — Wednesday, 1 October, 2008 @ 17:28

  7. How dare you eiden
    for saying Rachel should not be in the live shows!
    She not going anywhere.

    Comment by Gavin Martin — Thursday, 2 October, 2008 @ 22:12

  8. Glad Austin and Diana are through. Really wanted Ruth to go through aswell, not Rachel!

    Comment by Paul — Friday, 3 October, 2008 @ 16:50

  9. I can’t believe Liam Payne didn’t get through! I really wanted him to win.. he’s really hot as well! :(
    Ah well, at least Austin got though ;)
    Oh, and Diana!

    Comment by Livvy — Saturday, 4 October, 2008 @ 19:22

  10. Yay!!!! eoghan Quigg is through! i cant tell you how much i love tht boy:) x

    Comment by rea — Saturday, 4 October, 2008 @ 19:57

  11. OMG i cannot believe that Simon did not put that Liam Payne or Alan through that TOTALLY and UTTERLY SUCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Comment by victoria — Saturday, 4 October, 2008 @ 20:38

  12. if this is true im soooooooooooooooooooooooooooo happy

    eoghan quigg has got through and i love him sooo much he is gorgous

    i want him to win ….X

    Comment by charlotte harman — Saturday, 4 October, 2008 @ 22:05

  13. Where is Ruth?? Can’t belive Danni has choose Susan or Danni over her as she was the best of over 25s

    Comment by Rob — Saturday, 4 October, 2008 @ 22:21

  14. our family are all blown away by diana vickers she is special. xfactor don’t spoil her keep her the way she is. we can not wait for her first album.

    Comment by sprog — Saturday, 4 October, 2008 @ 23:37

  15. Pretty pleased with the selections (if they are true) particularly Cheryl’s group “the girls” and Simon’s “the boys”.

    Comment by Jennifer — Saturday, 4 October, 2008 @ 23:44

  16. Hmm i think the judges have got it all wrong this year , there were some better singers than a few that have got through

    Comment by tasha — Sunday, 5 October, 2008 @ 00:21

  17. I’m suprised Ruth is not on that Top 3 list.
    I’ve seen plently of lists knocking about the past few days, with Scott Bruton and Suzie Furlonger replaced by Alan Turner and Ruth Lorenzo respectively.

    Also, looking back at the bootcamp clips, they told Laura they judged them on there last performance.
    How did Joelle, with a few bum notes not get through, although they let Laura’s gibberish in?
    Don’t get me wrong, I really like Laura, but thought Joelle was as just a good vocalist.

    Comment by Simon — Sunday, 5 October, 2008 @ 01:24

  18. YAY! DIANA GOT THROUGH! The under 25s girls are amazing this year. Can’t believe that ruth didnt get through though :( LOVE SIMONS HOUSE!

    Comment by Emma — Sunday, 5 October, 2008 @ 06:49

  19. :( i can’t believe Amy didnt go through ..
    she was so pretty and amazing

    cheryl! we all thought you loved her!

    Comment by Carole — Sunday, 5 October, 2008 @ 09:23

  20. I think there are people through…that shouldn’t be there. Amy should have gone through….Rachel shouldn’t have.

    Laura White is AMAZING….She will win the whole show.

    Simon got it right by not putting Alan Through…HE IS A FAKE.

    Comment by cerrie lang — Sunday, 5 October, 2008 @ 10:56

  21. I am very much turned off by the emotionalism and weepiness of all the contestants and their sob stories. Surely an X Fator contestant should have panache, charisma, confidence as well as TALENT. Not one of them has displayed these qualities. I blame the judges for choosing them in the first place. With thousands of entrants, surely they could have selected better potential star quality singers (who DON’T weep and blub all the time)but are there to give of their best performances. e.g. NIKKI, last year’s 3rd place winner (despite a sad personal story) managed to rise above it and give OUTSTANDING PERFORMANCE (and in fact was far better than ANY of this year’s motley selection)! Maybe it’s time to change the judges who have obviously lost the plot, along with, seemingly as have the contestants.

    Comment by karen — Sunday, 5 October, 2008 @ 11:40

  22. I am completely turned off by all the weepyiness and emotionalism of the contestants. An XFactor winner (and all contestants) should display qualities of confidence, charisma and TALENT. I blame the judges who have surely chosen the wrong finalists. Amongst the thousands of entrants, is this the best they can come up with!

    Comment by karen — Sunday, 5 October, 2008 @ 11:45

  23. DIANA TO WIN :)
    I think Hannah should have gone through for the girls…

    and also Alan for the boys!

    The bands look pretty spot on but what about Ruth?

    If this is the final 12 i spot the winner!

    Comment by Princess1987 — Sunday, 5 October, 2008 @ 13:57

  24. omg amy is amazing i want her to win the show and dianna is soo cute.

    Comment by gina — Sunday, 5 October, 2008 @ 14:40

  25. If this list is true then I am glad that Alexandra got through. I liked her the moment she auditioned and I think she can win. I will be voting for her if she’s on the live shows. I am sure she will blow us away

    Comment by sona — Sunday, 5 October, 2008 @ 14:52

  26. i cant believe eoghan got through to the live finals he is a brilliant singer and hope he wins

    Comment by gemma — Sunday, 5 October, 2008 @ 18:18

  27. How on earth did Hannah not get through? that girl is class through and through, she sang with imagination, and terrific range and heart she is also an intelligent individual and not one of the ‘hello’ types. Cheryl big mistake

    Comment by millie — Sunday, 5 October, 2008 @ 18:19

  28. Why didn’t Hannah get through what a voice she may not look as glamourous as the other but her voice sent goose bumps through me such a shame
    does anyone else agree

    Comment by lb — Sunday, 5 October, 2008 @ 18:21

  29. Congratulations to dumb Cheryl Cole who has proved completely useless and made X Factor 2008 no longer interesting and worth to watch by denying a place in a final 12 to the only real talent Hannah! what a waste of space Cheryl is as judge, bring back Sharon, the wise woman! Simon put your money where the voice and talent is i.e. in Hannah!!!!!!!!!!!! get her out and we WILL buy her records!!!!!!!!!!

    Comment by Tatyana — Sunday, 5 October, 2008 @ 18:26

  30. simon cowell what were you thinking saying no to alan turner.do you think us girls want to look at a pontins throwback a boy slightly resembling a pig and the problem child. no i certainly dont. alan turner is what a pop star should look like. he was gorgeous dont worry alan try out for a model who needs shit factor.

    Comment by debbie gandy — Sunday, 5 October, 2008 @ 18:29

  31. I cannot believe that Cheryl has let Hannah go she must be mad,she is much better than Diana. Hannah could have won the competition.

    Comment by rose — Sunday, 5 October, 2008 @ 18:38

  32. well its official Dannie has lost the plot how can she put that Rachel through she can,t sing for toffee she forgot her words and gave a really bad performance she should never have progressed as far as she did. but the public will get rid as we want decent singers.
    but i also worry about the phone voting i don’t know how true it is but we will see.

    Comment by shelley — Sunday, 5 October, 2008 @ 19:03

  33. I was very disappointed that Cheryl didn’t pick Hannah Bradbeer, she had a very strong voice and a great stage presence and gave a riveting performance on Saturday. I would have loved to have seen her in the live shows, and felt that the girl chosen in her place with the blond hair gave a weaker performance and didn’t deserve to get through. I felt that all the other acts was the correct decision though.

    Comment by Elaine — Sunday, 5 October, 2008 @ 20:05

  34. I just love Diana Vickers so much … Think av got a fancy for her. Isn’t she just stuning though?

    Comment by Gary S — Sunday, 5 October, 2008 @ 21:37

  35. OMG i can’t believe how wrong Simon was. How could he not put Liam through i love him, unlike Eoghan he has looks as well as more talent. Simon is deluded i can’t believe Scott even got past bootcamp never mind in the final 3.

    Comment by Saz — Sunday, 5 October, 2008 @ 22:13

  36. It’s absolutely outrageous that Amy Connolly didn’t get through. I regret the day that I voted for Cheryl Cole in Pop Stars the Rivals who booted her out. The X Factor just won’t be the same from now on.

    Comment by Steve — Monday, 6 October, 2008 @ 02:39

  37. This is a shame…dropping a singer as talented as Hannah, from the final 12.
    Her vocals are far better than one or two who have gone through.
    Hope she makes it big, inspite of the Xfactor; cos she has it in her for sure.
    Pretty disappointed in CC as she seemed quite balanced in her selections, but probably does fall too much for sob-stories!
    Hannah has got a unique voice and looks; she looks quite comfortable in her skin and does not put up a pretence or show, like some of the others have.
    You could see it in the way she carried herself, after being told the journey is over–didn’t bawl all over Dermont ; walked away graciously.
    That, for me, tells me a lot more about this girl, than anything else.
    She sure will make it big!

    Comment by suja — Monday, 6 October, 2008 @ 10:26

  38. Hannah Bradbeer seemed to show an exceptional talent and its ashame that Cheryl Cole was to decide if she should go through.

    Hannah came across as confident and sang so well. I hope a record producer somewhere sees what totally went over Cheryl Coles head. That the most important thing is the voice and that special something. Look at Amy Winehouse.

    Comment by Emily Shaw — Monday, 6 October, 2008 @ 11:44

  39. Danni - needs her head read! Not putting through Suzie was stupid. Best voice by a mile in her group, and she look every bit a beautiful superstar and I hope that Simon may perhaps realise Danni’s error and sign her direct, rather than put her through the treadmill with Danni!

    Comment by Brett — Monday, 6 October, 2008 @ 12:07

  40. HANNAH BRADBEER was totally ROBBED!! There is NOOOO way Diana should have gone into the final 12. Hannah should be there!!

    Comment by Laura — Monday, 6 October, 2008 @ 23:35

  41. I can’t believe that Hannah Bradbeer didn’t get through. She was my favourite and she had an amazing voice. Cherly has made a big mistake by not putting her through. hope she comes back next year

    Comment by Diya — Tuesday, 7 October, 2008 @ 11:41

  42. didnt ruth go through instead of suzie furlonger?
    oh, can someone tell me what song scott was singing in boot camp?
    thanks.
    and yes, Theo, i really think that Joelle should have gone through. Amy as well.
    this year’s girls are really strong though =S
    i still cant make up my mind on who i like most

    Comment by Nicola — Wednesday, 8 October, 2008 @ 16:43

  43. talking about lifes a drag why hasnt anyone picked up on the fact that austin was in a series last year when he was asked to be in a band and the full back was that he had to and the rest of the band had to dress up as a women. the guy from scooch was in it too. they had to convince an audience that they were all women and not men does any one else remember that it was on e4 i think last year.

    Comment by frank — Saturday, 11 October, 2008 @ 08:12

  44. Aiden this is a singing contest not a popularity contest. Thing about many rude a… celebrities there are out there. Does it stop you from going to see their films, watching TV programmes, get a grip!

    Comment by Katie — Saturday, 11 October, 2008 @ 19:38

  45. i think they all did ok, jls were brill.
    diana is such a liar, saying she has only ever sung in school plays, she was at a search for a star final 3 years ago. she didnt win though so maybe thats why she didnt mention it, still shes lost my vote.

    Comment by lindsay — Saturday, 11 October, 2008 @ 20:47

  46. Diana Vickers to Win , she is so awsome :)

    Comment by Jamie Milton — Sunday, 12 October, 2008 @ 10:32

  47. How did hannah not get through? Shes like the best out of all of them. And 4 instinct. They picked the wrong people! Hannah and 4 instinct should be there!

    Comment by Leah — Sunday, 12 October, 2008 @ 12:07

  48. did any of you know that ‘ASTON MERRYGOLD’ out of ‘JLS’ is ‘COOKIE’ out of ‘FUN SONG FACTORY’ on the citv kids channel????

    Comment by katie — Sunday, 12 October, 2008 @ 21:02

  49. am i the first to notice, that aston from JLS is cookie from the CITV program fun song factory!!
    he didnt mention that in his vt

    Comment by gemma — Sunday, 12 October, 2008 @ 22:06

  50. EOGHEN TO WINNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN
    OR
    DIANNA

    We love Eoghan…. He said last week that he doesnt want a gf that the xfactor was more important but he hasnt seen us yet!!!! He is soooooooooooooo cute…:D

    Dianna has such talent…..

    Comment by Sligogirlies — Monday, 13 October, 2008 @ 14:36

  51. Laura, has got it all, looks powerfull voice, Wow factor! JLS could be her comp. though. Simons {cry boy~
    Scott, if that is the one who was given a bad song. he looks like Dermots son!

    Comment by donsonone — Monday, 13 October, 2008 @ 14:40

  52. JLS to win there well the best in the competition :)

    Comment by Leah.. — Monday, 13 October, 2008 @ 15:07

  53. Omg Austin has to win!!! Hes got an amazin voice and is gorgeous. Hes is the best this year

    Comment by AustinToWinnn!!! — Monday, 13 October, 2008 @ 18:44

  54. Omg Austin has to win!!! Hes got an amazin voice and is gorgeous. He is the best this year

    Comment by AustinToWinnn!!! — Monday, 13 October, 2008 @ 18:44

  55. Has anyone understood a single word Diana has “sung” so far? Why does she put on such a ridiculous accent, and the New Kate Bush act is wet. Her voice is weak, the other girls outsing her by a mile.

    Comment by Clair — Monday, 13 October, 2008 @ 20:23

  56. omg scott bruton is quality ;) he defo deserves 2 b der and JLS and eoghan are amazing :) one of dem 3 2 win xx

    Comment by sam — Tuesday, 14 October, 2008 @ 13:15

  57. Diana to win!!! She’s far more talented than the rest of the usual crap that comes on the show. She’s original :D x

    Comment by Kara — Thursday, 16 October, 2008 @ 17:45

  58. I think Diana is copying Dolores O’Riordan, lead singer of The Cranberries. Have a listen. If she is, she doesn’t deserve to be in the final 12 as she isn’t ‘unique’.

    Comment by Susie — Saturday, 18 October, 2008 @ 20:09

  59. Diana to WIN!! The has all the unique qualities required to be successful in the charts, plus she is beautiful!! Good Luck Diana, got my vote.

    ALL THE BEST :)

    Iain

    Comment by Iain — Saturday, 18 October, 2008 @ 20:40

  60. DIANA VICKERS TO WIN! There is without a doubt some tough competition this year but Diana has such an original sound and a magical way of captuing the audience that no one else has. I would love to buy her album and wish her all the best! I hope the public see what I see!

    Comment by Claire — Saturday, 18 October, 2008 @ 22:38

  61. rite, for starters….I totally agree with Clair, Diana’s incessant mumbling and apparent inability to finish off her words really annoy me, and as for the judges comments of her being ” unique”…utter tosh! She is nothing more than a 3rd rate Norah Jones wannabe….Hannah was indeed robbed, but to be honest with Cheryl Cole picking the final three for the catagory, what did u expect? She is herself manufactured tripe and wouldn’t know talent if it smacked her in the face…..shame Ruth in bottom two, should have been Daniel…..After last weeks performance of ” Fallin” im championing Laura to win!!! Go Laura!!!!

    Comment by donna — Saturday, 18 October, 2008 @ 23:09

  62. ps…Rachel is ghastly!!! Dont know how she dare be on national telly babbling about how she was on drugs and turned her life around! Any one else notice that two of her kids are still in care??? Obviously she hasn’t made that much of an effort to change, or she would have em back! Shame X Factor doesnt give these opportunities to more deserving, hard working folk instead of a drain on society like Rachel

    Comment by dondons — Saturday, 18 October, 2008 @ 23:21

  63. scott bruton is so fit ;-)

    and sadly i think austin doesn’t fancy women ;-(

    Comment by grace — Sunday, 19 October, 2008 @ 13:06

  64. love jls,think they are great. i also love scott bruton and eoghen quigg think they are hot and also one of the boys from jls is fit too. dont know his name. alexandra has a great voice and will sail through to the final. love them all, think there all great contestents this year.xx

    Comment by shannon — Sunday, 19 October, 2008 @ 13:42

  65. please can you tell me were diana’s dress was from she wore on tonights show (18th oct)

    Comment by helen — Sunday, 19 October, 2008 @ 16:06

  66. I HATE Rachel! She has far to much attitude she cannot sing of course unless its something by Amy Wino!
    I just cannot believe she is still in the compition.My prediction for the Final 4 is Alexandra, Laura , Diana and Jls! over all Alexandra!
    I dont know anyone of yet who likes rachel.Shes mad mannered, rude , mouthy and she needs to learn to shut up when the Judges speek to her! she has to go

    Comment by stacie — Monday, 20 October, 2008 @ 11:54

  67. BRING BACK SHARON AND LOOSE DANNI! she is bitter with her jelous screwed up face Saturday whilst Cheryl was performing.Btw Love Cheryl thats girl is Awsome!

    Comment by stacie — Monday, 20 October, 2008 @ 11:56

  68. if the xfactors about makin peoples dreams come true then they shouldn’t have to sing a theme that doesn’t suite them they should be able to sing what there good at and what they like you shouldn’t be deciding what they should sing because what if they sing it and the judges say well that does not suite ur voice or you should have picked a better song

    Comment by lisa — Monday, 20 October, 2008 @ 15:48

  69. Hi, I think that Eoghan, Diana and JLS will make the final. Love all three.

    Comment by Anne — Monday, 20 October, 2008 @ 16:04

  70. omg diana has to win! She’s the best thats ever bin on the show (except for Leona!)

    Comment by em — Monday, 20 October, 2008 @ 18:33

  71. Diana’s voice is so annoying! She is so weak and i dont like the fact that she can slide off notes and sing out of tune and get away with it because of her type of voice. I could never listen to her for more that 5 minutes.
    Laura has an amazing voice, its unique and strong.
    Luvin her :)
    Austin is good 2! x

    Comment by Sharon — Tuesday, 21 October, 2008 @ 12:51

  72. I totally agree with Donna and Sharon that Diana is completely over-rated.I work in the profession and I agree her voice is “unique”.She has probably been more out of tune than any other finalist in the history of the competition. I know that the X Factor is not about the best singer winning. Leon proved that last year but for some of the contributors to say that Diana is as good as Leona Lewis is beyond belief.
    Hopefully common sense will prevail and either Laura, Austin or JLS will win. They can sing and they are commercial.

    Comment by James — Wednesday, 22 October, 2008 @ 23:14

  73. i think that JLS are trying to be the new tellytubbies

    have you noticed that they always wear the same colours each week

    i think the red one’s marvin
    etc hehehehe

    tbh i think its quite funni, dont yell at me if u dont!!!! :p

    Comment by aimz — Saturday, 25 October, 2008 @ 20:04

  74. I think Diana Vickers is copying Dolores O’Riorden and I was surprised to read that others think so too. There was another girl who was sent away instead of Diana and she was fabulous. She should have been chosen instead. She had a far superior voice.

    Comment by Linda — Saturday, 25 October, 2008 @ 21:08

  75. why was ruth not in the heros song????

    Comment by natalie — Saturday, 25 October, 2008 @ 21:25

  76. I was at The Urban Smuggler office during the week, popped out for a smoke and bumped into Rachel Hylton, Brian Freidman and Scott, Really nice bunch, Rachel was so nice in person, it shocked Me and Feel she has been misjudged, Go Rachel you represent the less fortunate in this country,All The best

    Pete Morgan

    Comment by Pete Morgan — Saturday, 25 October, 2008 @ 21:32

  77. OMG…. The judges got it so wrong tonight. Daniel is a honey but Scott was by far the better at the end. This show should be about talent, not sympathy!

    Comment by Fiona — Saturday, 25 October, 2008 @ 21:55

  78. scot u didn’t deserve to go :S ROSIE xx

    Comment by rosie — Saturday, 25 October, 2008 @ 22:28

  79. Please stop voting for Rachael. She does not deserve any recognition whether she has talent or not. I am sick and tired of this continuous theme especially from Simon that she deserves a break. No! She doesn’t! It was her choice to lead the life that she has lead. If she had turned her life around so much, why are her children still in care? If anyone deserves a break it is all the hard working, law abiding people that don’t lower themselves to the depths that she still wallows in. I will lose all faith in this show and the general public if she is kept in any longer and given the one thing she wants MORE than her family - fame!

    Comment by ladylips — Sunday, 26 October, 2008 @ 01:50

  80. oh my god wat the hell is diana meant to be. and wats with the hand its like its going attack her ugly face. she is perfectic, and puts on a sweet face 2 win. sort the hand out love. it looks disgusting just like ya face. from taudi tillie callum jordan even my mother and father, louise and tristan and the to kids

    Comment by taudi — Sunday, 26 October, 2008 @ 16:10

  81. Just wanted to Wish Eoghan (SIR) all the very best, he making all us back home in Co. derry very proud…You can go all the way Eoghan, you and your family deserve it so much. you have outstanding talent..
    Dungiven Has Went Eoghan mad, wish you could see it sir u wouldnt believe your eyes!!!
    Anyway we all love you and take care and good luck sir!!!
    xxxxxxxxxxxxxx

    Comment by lea — Sunday, 26 October, 2008 @ 19:48

  82. “Diana’s voice is so annoying! She is so weak and i dont like the fact that she can slide off notes and sing out of tune and get away with it because of her type of voice. I could never listen to her for more that 5 minutes.”

    Biggest amount of rubbish i’ve ever heard! She’s absolutely gorgeous and sososo talented. “Her type of voice” is so new and different and like noone else around atm. Unlike JLS or bloody Rachel (arrrrgh!) who might be talented but are tooo much like everything else going on atm. Diana is the clearest winner as she is sooo talented, and completely different and doesn’t follow the crowd. But the standard this year is sooo good, she’s really got to put up a good fight. But she can do it, if she wasn’t talented she wouldn’t of got to where she is without even being in the bottom two. Diana to winnnnnn :)

    Comment by yourmotherrrr — Sunday, 26 October, 2008 @ 20:18

  83. omg diana is awsome and cheryl has defo got the strongest catogorie andi love eoghan and austin too, n jls the little 1 is absulutly gawjesss
    love yhoo all and whoeva thinks diana is boring and carnt sing you lot got really bad taste in music shes is awsome shes mii winner

    Comment by natasha — Tuesday, 28 October, 2008 @ 12:26

  84. Dianas not a bad singer, but she’s managed to make every song sound the same. I dont think its fai that all the others have had to stretch themselves, whereas she’s just sung every type of song in the same way, with her shoes off…..also if she doesnt stop twisting her hand round her face im gonna throw something at the tv!!!

    Comment by lil lady — Saturday, 1 November, 2008 @ 20:44

  85. Tonights X factor was a disgrace - it must be fixed. How could the judges chose rachel over austin. The better singer has been voted out by an old gay man - yes you louis - cos you dont want any real competition for your last act. The judges on this show must be deaf as well as stupid. Bring back sharon, at least she knows good music. The show is now full of crap acts like rachel, daniel, eioghan that can’t sing and every song they do sing sounds just like the last. Well done X factor, I didn’t think you could get any worse.

    Comment by gillian mills — Saturday, 1 November, 2008 @ 22:54

  86. Austin should of not gone home, he is a fantastic singer, great looking, nice personalty and everythin. He’s one of the best singers out. I was hoping Austin would win xfactor he has great pottenial and he should defintely carrying on singing. He should be proud how far he came and he should hold his head up high. Now I hope either Diana, laura or Alexander wins.

    Comment by Natalie Wood — Saturday, 1 November, 2008 @ 23:12

  87. yet again cant believe austen went out and daniel stayed in as for rachel she is a great singer but her attitude stinks she is so cocky i wouldnt vote for her

    Comment by olive — Sunday, 2 November, 2008 @ 14:07

  88. EOGHAN!!!! i love him… well not really love but i think he is awesome. its one of thoses crushes where you cant think of anything else at all and your palms go sweaty when you see them. omg l0ve him. wish i could meet hi sometime.
    Cant believe Austin got kicked out he was my second fav along with Diana.
    Austins version of Billie jean was awesome but for me now its Eoghan all the way to win….

    Comment by Aimee Bowden 14 — Sunday, 2 November, 2008 @ 18:31

  89. Well I Think JLS Or Diana Vickers Should Win There Both Amazing And JLS Are HOT :P

    Good Luck Guys ;) x

    Comment by chelsea — Sunday, 2 November, 2008 @ 18:45

  90. JLS All The Way There Absolutly Amazing Im Obsessed Wit Them ;) xGood Luck JLS x

    Comment by amber — Sunday, 2 November, 2008 @ 18:46

  91. I think Rachel could possibly sing ok, but she is too self willed to accept any guidance, she is clearly delusional, tonight watching her sing was car crash tv. A low life baby mama at heart. Austin drage could have been great, I do not like louise Walsh.

    Comment by Jim — Saturday, 8 November, 2008 @ 22:48

  92. RUTH… JUS GO HOME! nobody cares. I am very disgusted with the show this year as all the talented contestants are being voted off. The contestants remaing are people who either have sob stories ..hmm sympathy vote!?! scot or daniel? humm! or people who are not actually talented, who scream coz they cant sing so instead they get there boosoms out! or hiccup(squeek)…and dont turn upto perform coz there no so well ahhh!…..although..2weeks before laura was ill but still managed to perform an oustanding performance. some one answer to why this show has let it self down, surley simon has more sense. although tonight he didnt vote with his head he voted with his ***** why send laura home u no she was a winner scot was hot too, tut tut tut

    Comment by judge — Saturday, 8 November, 2008 @ 22:50

  93. I think it’s absolutely disgraceful that Diana was smuggled through to next week. Obviosly she couldn’t hack it wih a Mariah Carey number, and they all knew it. But she wasn’t so ill she couldn’t slap 10 pints of slime on her lips, or a ton of kohl on her eyes. What a sham

    Comment by Clair — Saturday, 8 November, 2008 @ 23:03

  94. WRONG DECISSION FOR LAURA TO GO HOME. Its just a competition for the judges to compete against each other, never mind the singers. Laura is 100% better than Ruth, every week (SPOKE BY ALL JUDGES) Laura was amazing and made the night every time she sang, I am so dissapointed in the result from Simon, just because he fancies Ruth, Ruth gets to stay, they know that Ruth is going home soon, to be in the bottom 2 again, so why oh why did they not give Laura a chance to stay, knowing she might have even been in the final, I wont be watching X Factor next year, its a fix and silly, compared to the results over the last two weeks. Thanx.

    Comment by ansogeutlah1 — Saturday, 8 November, 2008 @ 23:47

  95. hiyahh * OMG eoghan quigg is so hot :P …i love him so much …..:) his hair is unbelievably cutee …..He 4m derry n im frm fermanagh so ill bee cherring him n d hole waii :)……hez a n excellent singer and congratulations too his mum hu had a babii girl she gawjuzz* …al i wana saii his best of luck eoghan….can NOT believe laura went home …:(:( aww wel itz nli a competition ..:)itl bee a tough competition eoghan babe…:P..but yhu will make it all d waii …. ..jls are alsoo gud ….1 of u are amingly cut dnt kno your name tho …but eoghan i lovee you sooo much best of lUCK.LOVE YOU xxx.XxXxXxXxXxXxXxXxXxXxXXXxXXxXxXxxxXXxxXxxXxX

    Comment by Laura — Sunday, 9 November, 2008 @ 11:34

  96. Oh dear. Laura should not have left last night.

    Comment by chloe — Sunday, 9 November, 2008 @ 14:02

  97. Am I the only one who thinks Diane shouldn’t even be in this show? She has been off key most of the time, cannot hold a note without yodelling or shouting and thegimic is the same EVERY week. the fact she got through on a bad throat whilst 2 EXCELLENT singers were in the bottom 2 makes this show a complete farce. obviously the judges are all tone deaf as they strangely think she’s a great singer. Sorry Diane, no offence meant as I’m sure you are a lovely person but this pandering is beyond belief.

    Comment by blondedate — Friday, 14 November, 2008 @ 17:54

  98. JLS All The Way Amazing Group,
    Sooooooo Hot
    Good Luck XOXOXOXOX

    Comment by Aimee — Friday, 14 November, 2008 @ 21:03

  99. well well im sorry but rachel was great but jls was brilliant. they both shouldnt have been in the sing off. Diana Vickers was only in as she was drownd out by the backing singers. thank goodness she is awful. sorry but you are.way to go alexandra you deserve to win. sorry diana its a fix if you win.

    Comment by julie — Saturday, 22 November, 2008 @ 22:57

  100. oh and by the way diana is like kermit the frog meets the cranberrys.

    Comment by julie — Saturday, 22 November, 2008 @ 22:58

  101. Definately agree, JLS has to win, we need another boyband, Alexandra is amazing, but no different to leona lewis really, and Euoghan, too young, and childish, come back in a few years, and soory diana but you had to go, you were terrible!! What is with your weird voice??? and your bare feet!!!!!

    Comment by Chloe — Saturday, 6 December, 2008 @ 23:04

  102. JLS is the best and they always trie there hard, and
    Alexandra is the secend 1 she is the best
    and her voice is good

    Comment by maryan — Monday, 8 December, 2008 @ 13:59

RSS feed for comments on this post. | TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

XHTML ( You can use these tags): <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong> .