Saturday, 10 November, 2007

Andy out after showdown with Beverley

For once on the X Factor 2007 the two acts with the worst performances of the night were in the bottom two – Andy, mentored by Dannii Minogue, and Beverley mentored by Louis Walsh.

After both the judges backing their own acts, and Sharon Osbourne opting to send Andy home, the final decision was left to Simon Cowell. If he voted to keep Andy it would be left to the public vote, if he voted to keep Beverley then she would stay in the competition.

In the event Simon said that “both performances were very poor tonight”, but he had to decide who he thought the public wanted to keep.

That person was Beverley, leaving a tearful Andy out of X Factor 2007.


  1. Simon isnt alwasy right you know,just because x factors his show,he thinks hope are fantastic….say no more!!!

    yes i agree with andy,but beverley!!!No way,she was B E A U T I F U L

    go bevvy!!!!

    Comment by lee — Saturday, 10 November, 2007 @ 22:48

  2. Does anyone know where I can get that t-shirt Andy wore last night

    Comment by murray — Sunday, 11 November, 2007 @ 10:11

  3. Beverley should’nt have been in the bottom two. We tried to vote for her but you CAN’T GET THROUGH, what happened to text voting.

    Comment by Andy — Sunday, 11 November, 2007 @ 10:28

  4. Andy should not have gone everyone loved him! and he hadn’t peaked in the competiton yet, you could tell he wanted it so much by the way he sang that last song! I think people definately prefer andy!

    Comment by me — Sunday, 11 November, 2007 @ 10:53

  5. great performance rhydian…i believe in moved people when you sing…sooooooooo great!keep it up.goodluck

    Comment by GLOCEL — Sunday, 11 November, 2007 @ 13:37

  6. THE SHOWS FIXED!! first futureproof have gone now andy!! ANDY SHUDNT HAVE GONE!!!!!

    Comment by Asif — Sunday, 11 November, 2007 @ 15:50

  7. Why cant we vote off Louis Walsh. The self sanctimonious gay lepricorn….. The man has a definite eye/ear for all that is bland or middle of the road. Housewifes choice era 1974…..Dull, dull, dull, dull.dull. The man has pushed music back 3 decades. Oh please can we have 4 more talentless Irish lads covering a Gilbert O’Sullivan track…..aaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhhh!

    Comment by nacho Panza — Sunday, 11 November, 2007 @ 16:12

  8. Same difference is making a difference. Fresh, nice and jolly. I’m glad that misery Andy is gone. He will be a nice model though, good lookink fellow, that’s it.

    Comment by clara — Sunday, 11 November, 2007 @ 20:55

  9. TOTALLY WRONG DECISION! i think that beverley should have gone! She is boring.. i love andy he is absaloutly georgous and has a amazing voice! For once he tried something different and gets booted off the show! BOO BEVERLEY
    I cried when andy went :( BRING ANDY BACK!!
    now i want leon 2 win all the way x
    I cant stand beverly and rhydion!

    Comment by Danielle Turner — Sunday, 11 November, 2007 @ 21:13

  10. I also came on here looking for a way to find the top Andy wore last night, it was gorgeous! ANYONE KNOW WHERE I CAN GET IT?! :)

    Comment by Gareth — Monday, 12 November, 2007 @ 01:47

  11. leon and same difference i dontknow how they stay in

    Comment by lou — Monday, 12 November, 2007 @ 09:41

  12. who the hell does danni minogue think she is?
    she was a second rate popstar and what she knows about music can be forgotten in the blink of an eye get her off the show it doesnt work!

    Comment by mags — Monday, 12 November, 2007 @ 16:00

  13. Andy’s voice wasn’t strong enough for the song, however he did a better job on the 2nd go. Beverly’s voice was so much better. I still think nicki should win.

    Comment by Paul — Monday, 12 November, 2007 @ 16:49

  14. I can’t understand why the whole format has been changed. Why fix what isn’t broken? Danni is unnecessary and is upsetting the whole thing. The judges need 4 acts each, 3 is not enough which was proved when Sharon lost 2. If she loses her last act her heart won’t be in it for the next 6 weeks. The main problem however is the presenter, Dermot. He is dreadful and kisses all the men. He lacks personality and is not a patch on Kate Thornton. It needs a female presenter for the compassion if they can’t have Ant & Dec. I was an avid viewer of every series but it has not got the same desirability factor. Most of the contestants are not as talented as usual either.

    Comment by Diane — Tuesday, 13 November, 2007 @ 14:42

  15. I was a huge Andy fan so I am absolutely gutted.

    But putting all my bias aside, the one thing I don’t understand is that if Simon wanted the person that ‘the public liked most’ to stay in… why didn’t he vote Beverly to go, so that it would have gone the the PUBLIC vote?!

    How does he know who the public like best?

    If Andy had gone then, then fair enough, but he can’t claim he did it for the benefit of the public cos it just doesn’t make sense…

    Comment by Sian — Saturday, 17 November, 2007 @ 22:31

  16. Rhidion you rock.i think rhidion was actually the best
    out there i loved his song so much when he sang the song in the disco week.i liked the clothes he werea expetally and the men dancing and singing.Rhidion i hardly have to say you were the best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!.
    Alisha is good to but she always moves her and and i dont like the clothes she weres but she is improving every week well done alisha!try too bit leon ok?!.
    Beverley you rock!!!!!!!!!I love you but i didn’t like
    the song you sang in the disco week and when you said you are going to bit rhidion im sorry but rhidion bit you but you are my second best person in the xfactor .
    Leon i hate you!!!!!!!!!!!!!You are not good enough i think alisha was much better than you and the trousers you wored in the disco week not good but i liked you so much because of your beautiful noise i mean rock!!!!!!!!!!!!.
    Hope i like you very much all of you .you are to good to be in xfactor I love you!!!!!!But the clothes you always were are robish the simon about that but you rock.
    Niki you are my third best oh you,rhidion and berveley you are to good to be in xfactor thats why i said that rhidion is the best berveley senconnd and you third I love you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!.Good luk and may you or beverley or RHIDION win.
    Same different you rock too well done you luk great out there i cant wait to see you next week .bye

    Comment by nji — Friday, 23 November, 2007 @ 20:14

  17. I say go Rhydian, Rhydian to win! Were all supporting you. Go Danni and Rydian!

    Comment by Rachel — Saturday, 24 November, 2007 @ 20:21

  18. bev you were simply the best on the show dont feel like watching it now your gone girl all the best for your new future

    Comment by sarah — Sunday, 2 December, 2007 @ 21:36

RSS feed for comments on this post. | TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

XHTML ( You can use these tags): <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> .